Three plastic-free deodorants — a cardboard tube, an amber glass jar and a paper-wrapped stick — on a sunlit bathroom windowsill

Deodorant

How to choose a natural deodorant that actually works

Most people who say it doesn't work have hit one of two problems. Both are fixable, and neither means going back to aluminium.

"Natural deodorant doesn't work" is one of the most common things people say about this shelf, and it is almost always one of two specific problems rather than a general truth. Both are fixable.

The first is baking soda. It is what makes most natural deodorant effective, and on a minority of people it eventually causes a red, itchy rash. That is not an allergy and it does not mean natural deodorant is not for you — it means one ingredient is not.

The second is the adjustment period. Antiperspirant blocks the sweat duct; deodorant does not. Coming off one means sweating normally again for two to four weeks, and most people give up somewhere in there believing the new product has failed.

So the first question below is the one that actually decides everything: baking soda, or not.

If you have never had a problem

Start with a baking soda formula

Baking soda is the most effective odour neutraliser available without aluminium, and it is the reason most natural deodorants work at all. The majority of people wear it for years without any trouble.

It is also the cheapest way in. A Humble bar is $13 and lasts around three months, which makes it a low-stakes place to find out whether your skin gets on with it.

Humble Deodorant - Mountain Lavender

Humble Deodorant - Mountain Lavender

$13.00

Humble Deodorant - Black Spruce | Original Formula

Humble Deodorant - Black Spruce | Original Formula

$13.00

Bottle None Aluminum-Free Zero Waste Vegan Deodorant – Citrus Freshness

Bottle None Aluminum-Free Zero Waste Vegan Deodorant – Citrus Freshness

$20.00

Humble Deodorant - Patchouli & Copal | Original Formula

Humble Deodorant - Patchouli & Copal | Original Formula

$13.00

If you have had a red, itchy rash

Baking soda free — and it is not a downgrade

A rash that shows up a week or two in is almost always the baking soda, not the scent and not an allergy. Baking soda is alkaline and your skin is not; on some people that mismatch eventually causes irritation in the one place you cannot ignore it.

These use magnesium hydroxide or zinc instead. Marginally less powerful on your worst day, and vastly better than wearing nothing because the last one hurt.

HiBAR Plastic-Free Deodorant - Sensitive Skin (Pink Iris & Neroli)

HiBAR Plastic-Free Deodorant - Sensitive Skin (Pink Iris & Neroli)

$17.00

HiBAR Plastic-Free Deodorant - Sensitive Skin (Aloe & Sea Moss)

HiBAR Plastic-Free Deodorant - Sensitive Skin (Aloe & Sea Moss)

$17.00

HiBAR Plastic-Free Deodorant - Sensitive Skin (Unscented)

HiBAR Plastic-Free Deodorant - Sensitive Skin (Unscented)

$17.00

routine Natural Deodorant Cream - Johnny's Cash | Baking Soda Free

routine Natural Deodorant Cream - Johnny's Cash | Baking Soda Free

$28.00

Application

Stick or cream — it matters more than it sounds

routine makes the same formulas both ways, so this is a genuine choice rather than a difference in quality. A stick behaves like what you already know. A cream goes on with your fingers, which means you control the amount and it warms to your skin as you apply it.

People with sensitive underarms often prefer the cream, simply because nothing is being dragged across the skin. It feels odd for about three days and then it does not.

routine Natural Deodorant Cream - Sexy Sadie

routine Natural Deodorant Cream - Sexy Sadie

$28.00

routine Natural Deodorant Stick - Like a Boss | Full Strength

routine Natural Deodorant Stick - Like a Boss | Full Strength

$28.00

Lime & Bergamot Natural Deodorant

Lime & Bergamot Natural Deodorant

$22.00

If you sweat heavily

When the gentle option is not enough

Stronger formulas and more assertive scents, built for long days and hot ones.

Worth being straight about the limit: no natural deodorant stops you sweating. Nothing without aluminium can, because blocking the sweat duct is precisely what aluminium does. What these do is keep the odour under control through a full day of it.

Dr. Squatch All Natural Deodorant for Men - Wood Barrel Bourbon

Dr. Squatch All Natural Deodorant for Men - Wood Barrel Bourbon

$17.00

Humble Deodorant - Palo Santo & Frankincense | Original Formula

Humble Deodorant - Palo Santo & Frankincense | Original Formula

$14.00

routine Natural Deodorant Stick - Superstar | Charcoal

routine Natural Deodorant Stick - Superstar | Charcoal

$30.00

Not sure yet

Try one for $5 before committing to a $28 one

Because your skin needs a couple of weeks to give you a real answer, buying full size on a guess is an expensive way to experiment.

Travel sizes last long enough to get you through the adjustment period and tell you whether a formula suits you.

routine Natural Deodorant Mini - The Curator | Sensitive Skin

routine Natural Deodorant Mini - The Curator | Sensitive Skin

$5.00

Humble Deodorant - Bergamot & Ginger | Original Formula

Humble Deodorant - Bergamot & Ginger | Original Formula

$14.00

Humble Deodorant - Lavender & Holy Basil | Original Formula

Humble Deodorant - Lavender & Holy Basil | Original Formula

$14.00

Humble Deodorant - Mountain Lavender | Sensitive Skin Formula

Humble Deodorant - Mountain Lavender | Sensitive Skin Formula

$14.00

The first three weeks are the hard part

If you are switching from antiperspirant, expect two to four weeks of sweating more and smelling more than you are used to. Your sweat glands are returning to normal function and the skin bacteria that were being suppressed are coming back. It settles.

Two things get people through it. Wash with soap rather than just water, because the smell comes from bacteria and not from sweat itself. And reapply at midday for the first fortnight without treating that as evidence the deodorant has failed — it is the transition, not the product.

The one thing that is not part of the adjustment: a red, itchy rash. That is the baking soda, and the second section above is the answer to it.

Shop all natural deodorant